A few dozen times a year someone new will tell me they “really want their building to breathe.” Occasionally they are literally talking about fresh air ventilation in air-changes per hour (ACH) in which case I know what they really want is people inside the building to be able to breathe, the building only by extension. However, usually they really do mean the building itself. Since the building isn’t for the most part a living thing, why would they be so focused on a need to breathe? What do they mean? Then it dawns on me…
Even if we assume the term is not meant literally and instead is simply a way to describe an exchange of some sort, the code has tightened so dramatically over the last several years most that exchanges are pretty locked down. Your building can’t “breathe” air, at least not anymore. We require air barriers. Air flow through the wall is not allowed. You can’t “breathe” energy. You’re not allowed. We insulate the heck out of these buildings.
Buildings don’t need oxygen to survive only the people inside do. So what exactly do we mean when we say we want a building to breathe?So, what we’re left with is moisture.
We are accumulating moisture in our buildings faster than ever before. The problem is everything gets wet. Nothing new here but in the past with energy and air flowing freely through the envelope the moisture dried. We have regulated both the efficiency and tightness of our buildings so effectively we are now left to solve for m – moisture.
How do our buildings release excess moisture without energy flow or air flow?So what are our options? Some may suggest diffusion. Sure, but today’s buildings have seven, eight layers. Trying to diffuse that much moisture is a bit like trying to move a mountain with a Tonka toy. You’ll make progress, but too slowly to make much of a difference. My suggestion, divide your wall in two.
Think of the wall as two halves and suddenly, whole new ball gamePick a layer, somewhere in the middle, and designate this your barrier. Nothing gets past this point. Now you are looking at two wall systems. Everything from this layer in will be designed to dry inside and everything from this layer to the exterior can breathe (air).
So which layer is your barrier?I am going to suggest you make it the sheathing line. It can’t be inside the insulation. That’s your energy barrier, not allowed. Your sheathing is usually made from oriented strand board (OSB) making it a natural barrier. Moisture will move through it but not much and slowly.
Now that we have our barrier line, we just need to work on developing those two wall systems.
To which you may say, this sounds really interesting, but is it necessary?
What’s a little water between walls?That I suppose, depends on what the goals are for your structure? Is it to create a healthy environment in which all occupants can thrive? Then the answer is yes.
Excess moisture promotes mold growth and increases dust mite fecal matter in the air, both of which have negative effects on human health.
Is it to create a building that stands the test of time? Then the answer is yes.
Moisture in the envelope leads to premature material failure which then leads to structure failure.
Do buildings breathe?I don’t know if we can answer that with certainty, but I think we are learning that they most certainly should.